SCLs and M-Factors in CLP Mixture Classification

Valenc logo and the title: SCLs and M-Factors in CLP Mixture Classification

A specific concentration limit (SCL) is a substance-specific threshold that replaces the generic concentration limit for a particular hazard. An M-factor is a multiplier used for highly toxic aquatic ingredients in the summation method. Both are properties of the substance, not the mixture, and can classify a mixture that generic limits would not.

This explains why two reviewers may classify the same formula differently under the EU Classification, Labelling and Packaging (CLP) Regulation. One may use generic limits from a template, while the other checks the substance entry first.

The working rule

Check the substance entry for SCLs and M-factors before applying any generic threshold. Apply the CLP method separately for each hazard class. Record the concentration, data source, entry version, and calculation in the classification record.

GCLs, SCLs, M-factors and cut-off values: four different numbers

These four values are often treated as interchangeable percentages. They answer different questions.

ValueWhat it doesWhere it comes from
Generic concentration limit (GCL)The default threshold at which an ingredient’s hazard classifies the mixture.CLP Annex I, in the section for each hazard class.
Specific concentration limit (SCL)Replaces the GCL for one substance and one hazard. Mostly health hazards.Annex VI harmonized entries. Otherwise set by the manufacturer, importer or downstream user under Article 10.
M-factorMultiplies the concentration of an Aquatic Acute 1 or Aquatic Chronic 1 ingredient in the summation method.Annex VI where given. Otherwise set from aquatic toxicity data under Article 10.
Cut-off valueSets the concentration from which an ingredient has to be taken into account at all.CLP Annex I, Table 1.1, as adjusted by SCLs and M-factors.

A cut-off value is not a classification limit. If an ingredient exceeds its cut-off, it must be considered. Classification of the mixture depends on the specific limit or formula for that hazard class.

Where the numbers come from: Annex VI and Article 10

Begin with Annex VI, Part 3 of CLP, which lists harmonized classifications. If an entry includes an SCL or M-factor, that value is mandatory. A harmonized entry applies only to the hazard classes specified. For other hazard classes, self-classification is required.

Article 10 sets the rules. Regulation (EU) 2024/2865 replaced Article 10 and has applied since July 1, 2026. It now also covers acute toxicity estimates. Key points for mixtures include:

  • SCLs are set on evidence. A lower SCL is required where reliable scientific information shows the hazard is evident below the generic limit. A higher SCL is allowed only in exceptional circumstances.
  • No alternative SCL for a harmonized class. Where Annex VI covers the hazard class, a supplier cannot set its own SCL for it (Article 10(4)).
  • M-factors are required for every substance classified Aquatic Acute 1 or Aquatic Chronic 1. If Annex VI gives one, use it. If the entry gives none, set one from available data, and use it in the summation method (Article 10(5)).
  • SCLs take precedence over the generic limits in Annex I (Article 10(8)).
  • A mixture inside a mixture. Where a substance is classified solely because of an identified impurity, additive or individual constituent, the limits apply to the concentration of that impurity, additive or constituent in the mixture. Where a mixture contains another mixture, they apply to its concentration in the resulting final mixture (Article 10(10) and (11)).

Do not rely solely on a value from a supplier SDS as the complete legal analysis. Verify the substance identity, hazard category, current Annex VI entry, concentration in the final product, and whether the value is harmonized or self-classified.

How an SCL changes a health classification

The use of an SCL depends on whether the hazard class is additive.

Non-additive classes include sensitization, carcinogenicity, mutagenicity, and reproductive toxicity. Each ingredient is assessed against its own limit. If an ingredient has an SCL, that SCL is used as the limit.

Additive classes include skin corrosion, skin irritation, and serious eye damage or irritation. Ingredients are summed. According to Annex I, Table 3.2.3, skin corrosive ingredients totaling 5% or more classify the mixture as Skin Corr. 1, while totals from 1% to below 5% classify it as Skin Irrit. 2. If an ingredient has an SCL, that limit replaces the generic one for that ingredient in the calculation. ECHA’s Guidance on the Application of the CLP Criteria provides the formula.

Methylisothiazolinone (MIT, CAS 2682-20-4) shows the effect in a non-additive class. Its harmonized entry classifies it as Skin Sens. 1A with an SCL of 0.0015% for H317. The generic limit is 1% for a Category 1 or Sub-category 1B sensitizer and 0.1% for Sub-category 1A, so the SCL is far lower than either.

MIT in the mixtureAgainst the 0.1% generic limitAgainst the 0.0015% SCLResult
0.0020% (20 ppm)BelowAt or aboveMixture is Skin Sens. 1A, H317.
0.0005% (5 ppm)BelowBelowNot classified as a sensitizer. EUH208 applies.
0.0001% (1 ppm)BelowBelowNo sensitization labeling from this ingredient.

The middle row is often overlooked. A mixture not classified as sensitizing must still carry EUH208, “Contains (name of sensitising substance). May produce an allergic reaction,” if a sensitizer is present at or above the elicitation limit in Table 3.4.6. For sensitizers with an SCL below 0.1%, the limit is one tenth of the SCL. For MIT, this is 0.00015%, or 1.5 ppm.

Classification and elicitation are separate decisions with distinct thresholds. Record both, and always check the current Annex VI entry before relying on any figures here, as entries may be amended.

How M-factors change an aquatic classification

M-factors apply only to ingredients classified Aquatic Acute 1 or Aquatic Chronic 1. In the summation method in Annex I, section 4.1.3.5.5, the concentration of each such ingredient is multiplied by its M-factor before the sum is compared with 25%.

Check in orderSum of classified ingredientsMixture classification
AcuteAcute 1 × M ≥ 25%Aquatic Acute 1
Chronic, step 1Chronic 1 × M ≥ 25%Aquatic Chronic 1
Chronic, step 2(M × 10 × Chronic 1) + Chronic 2 ≥ 25%Aquatic Chronic 2
Chronic, step 3(M × 100 × Chronic 1) + (10 × Chronic 2) + Chronic 3 ≥ 25%Aquatic Chronic 3
Chronic, step 4Chronic 1 + Chronic 2 + Chronic 3 + Chronic 4 ≥ 25%Aquatic Chronic 4

Acute and chronic effects are assessed separately, and a substance may have a different M-factor for each. Chronic assessment steps are followed in sequence and stop once a criterion is met. The summation method is one part of the assessment. Where supported by data, test results on the mixture, bridging principles, and the additivity formula are also considered.

Determining the M-factor

If Annex VI does not specify an M-factor, refer to Annex I, Table 4.1.3, and use the substance’s aquatic toxicity to determine the value. Higher toxicity results in a larger M-factor.

Acute L(E)C50, mg/lAcute MChronic NOEC, mg/lChronic M, not rapidly degradableChronic M, rapidly degradable
Above 0.1 up to 11Above 0.01 up to 0.11None
Above 0.01 up to 0.110Above 0.001 up to 0.01101
Above 0.001 up to 0.01100Above 0.0001 up to 0.00110010
Above 0.0001 up to 0.0011,000Above 0.00001 up to 0.00011,000100

The table continues in factor-of-10 steps.

Worked example: 0.8% of a Chronic 1 ingredient with M = 10

A hypothetical mixture contains one aquatic ingredient, classified Aquatic Chronic 1, at 0.80%, with a chronic M-factor of 10. No other ingredient is classified for aquatic hazards.

  1. Apply the M-factor: 0.80 × 10 = 8.0%.

  2. Step 1, Chronic 1: 8.0% is below 25%. The mixture does not meet the criteria for Chronic 1.

  3. Step 2, Chronic 2: 10 × 8.0% = 80%. This exceeds 25%. The mixture is classified as Aquatic Chronic 2.

  4. Stop here. Do not proceed to Chronic 3, even if that threshold is also met.

Without the M-factor, the same ingredient would result in 10 × 0.80% = 8% at step 2 and 100 × 0.80% = 80% at step 3, classifying the mixture as Chronic 3. The M-factor increases the classification by one category. Acute classification requires a separate assessment using the acute M-factor.

The 0.1% cut-off does not hold for high M-factors

Annex I, section 4.1.3.1 considers Acute 1 and Chronic 1 ingredients relevant at concentrations of 0.1% or higher. For ingredients with an M-factor, the relevant concentration is (0.1/M)%. For example, with M = 100, this is 0.001%. Ignoring all ingredients below 0.1% may result in missing an aquatic classification.

If a relevant ingredient has no usable aquatic data, the mixture is classified on the known ingredients, and the label and SDS carry the statement “Contains x % of components with unknown hazards to the aquatic environment” (section 4.1.3.6).

A decision sequence for CLP mixture reviewers

  1. Establish the final formula, including substances, premixes, actual concentrations or controlled ranges, and product form. Break down each premix to its constituent substances.

  2. Gather ingredient classifications. Review the current Annex VI entry for each substance, then consider self-classifications, including SCLs and both acute and chronic M-factors.

  3. For each hazard class, decide whether test data on the mixture or bridging principles apply before turning to ingredient-based methods.

  4. When using ingredient-based methods, select the appropriate generic limit, SCL, additivity formula, or summation rule. Do not rely on thresholds solely because they appear in supplier templates.

  5. Perform acute and chronic aquatic summations separately, using the correct M-factor for each. Document all intermediate totals and the first category met.

  6. Review any concentration range that crosses a threshold. Use controlled formulation data to resolve it, or refer it to a qualified reviewer. Do not default to the lower value without justification.

  7. Verify elicitation limits for sensitizers and include EUH208 where applicable.

  8. Ensure the final classification aligns with the SDS and label, and retain data sources and calculation versions for future reference.

Common errors that change the final classification

ErrorWhy it mattersBetter control
Applying only the generic limitA lower SCL is missed.Look up substance and hazard-specific limits before calculating.
Treating 0.1% as a universal triggerCut-offs, GCLs and SCLs answer different questions.Use the rule for the hazard class and the values assigned to the substance.
Using the chronic M-factor for acuteAcute and chronic M-factors can differ.Hold separate M-factor fields and verify both.
Ignoring a high M-factor at low concentrationThe relevance cut-off falls to (0.1/M)%.Apply the M-adjusted cut-off, then the summation.
Classifying and stoppingEUH208 applies below the classification limit.Check elicitation limits for every sensitizer.
Stopping at the supplier SDSThe document may predate a change to the harmonized entry.Check the current entry and reconcile the record.
Carrying a CLP result into other marketsCLP limits and hazard classes are not identical to OSHA or WHMIS.Classify the product separately for each jurisdiction.

The newer CLP hazard classes are not additive

CLP now includes hazard classes for endocrine disruption, PBT, vPvB, PMT, and vPvM properties. These apply to new mixtures from May 1, 2026, and to existing mixtures by May 1, 2028. These classes are non-additive: each ingredient is assessed against the generic limit for its class and category, and M-factors are not used. Mixtures classified before these classes were introduced should be re-evaluated.

Keep the classification linked to SDS Sections 2 and 3

Classification is determined first and reported in the SDS. Section 2 includes the classification and label elements, which require a jurisdiction-specific review, as detailed in our Section 2 comparison for HazCom, WHMIS, and CLP. In an EU SDS, Section 3 lists the SCLs, M-factors, and acute toxicity estimates for each ingredient. For more details, see our page on EU SDS requirements under REACH and CLP.

An effective audit trail documents each ingredient, its entry version, the specific limit or factor used, calculations for each hazard class, the reviewer’s decision, and the final label and SDS. Any formulation change, new harmonized entry, or updated supplier classification should prompt a review of affected products.

This article covers EU CLP. Great Britain runs its own GB CLP with its own mandatory classification list, so GB values need a separate check. See UK SDS requirements.

How Valenc does it

Valenc’s GHS classification assesses approved compositions according to the published rules of the selected jurisdiction and displays the rule behind each result. The Annex VI harmonized entries, with their SCLs and M-factors, are in the Valenc database, so those values are applied in the calculation and do not have to be keyed in from a supplier SDS. It flags uncertainties, such as concentration ranges crossing thresholds, for human review. The goal is a classification that is clear and reproducible. To see this applied to your formulations, request a demo.

Frequently asked questions

What is a specific concentration limit under CLP?

A specific concentration limit is a threshold set for one substance and one hazard. At or above this level, the substance classifies the mixture for that hazard and replaces the generic concentration limit for that substance.

Does an SCL always override the generic concentration limit?

Yes, for that substance and hazard class. It does not override rules for other hazard classes or reliable test data for the mixture where applicable.

Are SCLs and M-factors the same thing?

No. An SCL is a concentration threshold, mainly for health hazards. An M-factor is a multiplier used only for Aquatic Acute 1 and Aquatic Chronic 1 ingredients in the summation method.

Do substances have separate acute and chronic M-factors?

Yes, substances can have separate acute and chronic M-factors. Check both, as one should not be substituted for the other.

Can a substance below 0.1% classify a mixture?

Yes. A low SCL can trigger a health classification, such as MIT at 15 ppm. An aquatic ingredient with a high M-factor is relevant from (0.1/M)% and can affect the summation result.

Where do I find an SCL or M-factor?

Begin with the harmonized entry in CLP Annex VI, Part 3. Then review the classification and labelling inventory and the supplier’s data for self-classified values, including the scientific basis. Document the source and version used.

Classify the mixture first, then author the SDS

Accurate EU classification requires more than listing ingredient hazard statements. Confirm the legally applicable values for each substance, apply the correct method for each hazard class, and ensure calculations are traceable. The process is: gather source data, determine SCLs and M-factors, classify the mixture, then prepare the SDS and label. Each step should be reviewable against the same product record.

See your formulations classified under EU CLP, with the rule behind each result.

← Back to all posts